In the 1920’s the Harleysville Mutual Insurance Company contracted with Hershey & Gibbel for their services as Managing General Agents. This relationship grew and prospered for over 60 years.

While serving the Lititz community, the Hershey & Gibbel local insurance agency developed into a professional, full service, independent insurance office. In 1993 the Hershey & Gibbel partnership was dissolved and Gibbel Insurance Agency, Inc was formed.  Jim Gibbel was the managing partner at Gibbel Insurance 1963 to 2010 when his son Ethan began managing the agency. 

Our home-grown business vision is led by Ethan Gibbel who represents the fourth generation of the agency and our intent to remain locally owned and locally committed to you and the community for generations to come.

Gibbel Insurance Agency, Inc has grown and expanded our services and products since it originated in 1890, but our underlying philosophy is the same: We strive to provide personalized service, customized coverage, and competitive prices to the Lancaster County area. Along with this goal, we value long term relationships that aim to continuously earn your trust.

You will find a complete range of insurance coverage services including health, life, employee benefits, auto, boat, motorcycle, homeowners, rental, flood, business, and much more. We do not just provide an insurance product – we provide security for our friends and neighbors.

Our staff is our heartbeat. You will find them committed to serving you with their friendly spirit and wealth of insurance knowledge. This makes doing business with the Gibbel Agency hassle free and give you the peace of mind that you and your loved ones are protected.